From 736a5892e6300c1ff66e920d227590916370794a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Marco Slot Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 12:14:40 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Add MX benchmarks diagram --- images/mx-dedicated-query-nodes.png | Bin 0 -> 12702 bytes src/backend/distributed/README.md | 14 ++------------ 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 12 deletions(-) create mode 100755 images/mx-dedicated-query-nodes.png diff --git a/images/mx-dedicated-query-nodes.png b/images/mx-dedicated-query-nodes.png new file mode 100755 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d7db99c1e352328cf2236c00ca61b224b9b1869b GIT binary patch literal 12702 zcmeHucUTkY*EX*1+F@N+2{pRd5G6*DgqmGh7nP=hqSS?mh}6&$YSsc#Nyu6dAqZk2 zx+q1Ymne{lfPjMZ5@85zC_)liAmtmt->wDMy}tK-|M|X`>za!^^URz%=RW7$=R8j) z7Y~{nuUw|MOh!g#<^Fv?AC{5%3XqXmP`+g0%$e)TtDt`i{0($dm8`v-ma*|+@o@#A)OcEA4m>xmO5PMtdC?(Xj4;eo^9 z{QUd^0|SGCf`WsC!^6YRo;@285kVr6E?v456%|FHP^eVul`B_bVq$LGxIv@Q5)u-U zl9KM+xkIPZA3S)FnwpxHmX?{BnU$6G5EiN&Tz#3?}Ir9S(P`^m`2L&(UlT2Q%3 zfRT~ev1k9!KUonRhB}rL)tWAMI`!?TIpt>m%W=z#Puzn!_IeJdom)mXm~YZ>bMY;a z8n^nHOAAvAUZIEAFP5P#9us-2JT^A|H6=drn|)s~CYg?V2wf6OQ{10FDuQzBi%ubd zDS>!i|7NdXstwC<@$rgG13SkO@FdBZj3w)hcwj?AkgAQ-2t-LG z(NNR{xhe`F#j8t32AbsMV;!YPw!|>zss%$Ry|=qRoD2^a_u|_<_~L=6+;-7Omjy9N z?xapQx05J*TUMQ#q#7^}G|geJ0oU zvWpbtJuk~X{dEkMR4TByBGa+GIx20ob@^bIg=5M&+UX?mSQ!Z}9jVv>a9)}E8HQM4 zoXPa`L?`luD8dFu4C7g}zb?@r@>ou$#)2ftc-MNf6D?V!VFAXU>wjEg01~2mO?p|J zLQ$U_cfl!tX;peXBRR-@=nnB%EeZg+1emLyKws2rd-@J9qc&AcMQhWJ{@#+x8rM1rK%&b zt_4ZG#3t@tOsApfq>VVVEm0+jmdSJr3i2#E_HujN+7VXsQ1y$^i48*u20ntUT6F^u zMi05EI^4CRUDyZXWH|6Q=qboecWDzKQh8gKWgWM@+KxTc4GZGA zDc-cYb5*iMkJ;bXHlE^SYO=$Y%(J(tb9iu{!kccAEb5*(dD7+!ATUEEqoK>G zz;yXtI#sx8i(~ji*ZP}h`rK7=nOEF~gp0;HGUBsi?jneJTk)qe?|Ujmg-?0wa(g!~ z!MbKn33H0w?!r1ZY_B?z-$Zf8CTL5+ky2NkvBKiGxW)nV?HGObJziEcPPG#exzLcI zWnNk3ExZ@Cp?Z{t5{hjX%nHXe&C_i_%^z`v53-IyZgOaK0Ac5Tx4qIy(|?{nFn%(cr-GN{=o^AZYPkjj zFnU=vwqO?kSFKzZtI^KQkaLVipAR&=k+vkO>s4aBpewFK5gut(LFJEfd>?7X4(MTv z3a|a#c|lx;O>1>xf(PBL;C1LY=T^? z&lbr`&#n03GS)*G1;Z5d! zK`er9sD|8uE3(d-7Obsi2F7||SGM(qNYbqYW>(QlV=~X$CK^(}P$>aEOT4RyT| zJO7f+n&x+ko?lLnVAVK}2|PpUUzwU@Ow>PisD}xxpN*eP7S;cLbXfIwD_fz7-*-w1 zpg(rPCl+hgx=+ha^S5s%^QY4U|QgI8Qi>jB#mXVRy-0m+S6^mnmeNu8d$Yen+9= zsPx!LNN6)@#gJ~y1OGcdY>%I^xnvgTnRpT#WZ5nBPto@ z?{G3u`URgW_+fcAGSTb!#p2_Y?#DyZHwDGvT`bZ_dD~|2oOu8z# zKtioy8SAiN)WID!;CB;6d}@bZjW1c=T?Kw?)YZmfYB(>eotB5l>!RbDFt2Afk7>zFgmJiy}9jkP3c%A<~z>%=VzD~OdU0wD!&7RRVB#kL*em9 zv>z8(#2#&T{CkaCo&edq{jp$}oqGbt4YZYD_MS2y*StK!K6ZHCrJz~c9` zh|1Kjx%st()Be#0K=$lq^ye1Fm}(3rYdoR%IlZDkhYBPH$lFfi*8!9JCEnq>1${cz znbPcZ&*@XnWFvGA419U!zx$x7f{R1Sc>cQ>Dwaa~k;62vN7weC6R0YnD4YyhbvlG! z1}4P=-h%12d)@x-_r5P(5Y_{uXBH`u_>%s@0WAO}TnUG#)f4Hq8uy$oe=FM!rc>z1 z5}~M13z)FxsJM6`*k-wsBHK%N_;Qke9x_~7QApC7=}{1t0R>}i9d#M|mXL56$Qrc- zX>BZ*%5B69Uay3AI_^33tZ19E2YJ|mgBMYevMeSvJWZ}T;%#Sjz7KaFnP|9#lPlbq z&EJ+*ly}{`xMMrhvdCv2DdbY@iY6B5e!Biq65fP&))syD92GaEdlOeB3@pe#ysYat zLtnD6S*Iq=goOhe>}izn z%7l;nnic8Es-<-cSOkK~qoTV<6PaeYiI8G*r@MejZQ?`LZhCxKr7PV*mPW zDjwu2QoSjvQaG-LDUIyf{o3f*)N{xcr758ZU3GSq-V5XA9YvABOHANIZ9~P#rh{@$ z>Hyk*-3P~HkWZ|#VwbuzIcYJzB6(Hf55T`Ub=!$7%wJkGb&>yy2dQKKMpH+t)KWi~ zObZA2>j;FEW14evZ4g`E0`PQ+zB-+0~>E&{^P#`}i||-G>Bf&;2#1#)jIak-TOS&Htg5Hvs!P4+DRP);@WMJ^_goFsNi>c`!$mAt|2oHJ`q z3V;mH(@ZkYa-SNc@-@$e82*X9_xd+h#lhjP{<6y^oiZUZJ*a4+n=Lm*XmurypcUpo z?0>GSRbwY;LEj9Bx=AOL!I}*J1TQ9upM9i56JW|KL8cXN#uu4QX#Nd^gViAF#fGc- zQ%jd_hsS4}{qVUtJAu&0=RU+m=|xp(GBAlnY;E38{or!#8?h1N$dU?cfTPgbjt2CD zY=yU|lY>5|8}A-0BWqEG-Z>Xeu&{CY=Y)y{`aWj!-4BQy2TLK z{2@qw9|X@MtmwYC8vGmT)#T2v|H6KEG;dN27BgOaq5&G<4N(_@P>#&Gm&_B)B+T4k zARCEM9F>f59ely}BWcO`m17Q1FiZ`$_<}c4dC5CV*MF=1I^>luAZiW`od$n=XXeT? z8Ofbd<48jt*}T7XGFsy4xe;NzUVmLW z8}V~e8j&@O?90TXe!Mm~t9;%|0AvlDS;#nmRZdqzWOzpw{MbC3v2)6yfuQqMFg6ob zoB7ccuNfJg#rtad z%zG^bEAqLy>51rCTjFqc4Bl5`_~p^?j{V`+%@#t?mTVuSC2M{gILjEb9@2{DjX1Y) z3X9oHFw3p3B6#XrJQuKeuwZffLH645>Vxu2^kzLhtF|h%64^HqHVtlS8cr`cAhp=s zuFr3%eOy7@qU>W7X4{N1vR^kiOLX5ZQR*)yl<(aelsXy4mJp;<4Hj}u4_d}^1VXup zd3CS0;MKX{65se9&)DRM?&~Agx2afT7HyCw`#fDa=IO*<5pX7BmNMr63m{|KudyAw z%L}^4yX%{Tu||pLS%R3y=@R}9#PVwFwrh?$#U_5D@~CBjb>MGG{cWWs3jJR>&GJFy zkIe^(K@e*!q+}L9cJ0gfsKqIM#~pJme?$p~(e-~vQT&WKFVE)Ys35$S%j&} zwN#LV92f);`@h*tWTCg-ejREl*}?~q2vlUSd9d;po=M`-DfV2)O-o9$HV zK5LGaqY|A*dr0Ap%F5KUUYnvC53KzB#YvQ}I}h(VE-Z?N>h))%g`@~_*N~wGc+=l( zK5JRc8KAi)!y+_SxJFs$Q(BvaMpheOR1RxgI~k`ysg>MU`_Z$AvYpAazgc%CG9+Y(XU^TER9XB$PwmXRe`?R)C1@5v zK9}N+N>?}240G%;Zq8T*@wdnO)osqxAWUxf(B*G3*eHgx+Dy58zbwq@WK6~d?Y_;% zul(!#G=Se} zepb!(K76SX5-R*3)b4jfoEFp`2P-cy67Ori0F^uK_Zx)&4DVb-s%Fk>?o4erhW15J zp=`A@$~?e9S5edqTRr5a_BAeXs%|aRUSCLbf=SO{34MB6% zrPbX_VEx9Wzsyv>_lx&`hRSAS-USK_a_`5W&0vU*2asN3g)XBnN`bcb9hofzmCuN2 zjJnjAJEgNO`nTlp4f99TEHGM*RwD(f;`UQ^Hi zgK;o$)jz}m5>T5r*k)o6JQdGE6OD9Nuvc`^^`h2cz>|SlS77a%r{18m!0} zTEYK=kH(Q}JBj?XqKdYtu-y5xf6gH`tYgItoN8BB@iLM^SP-;q{Cv>M2p+#g1AH+> zupEa36lMg>ET(5V!*}EY%0LtgAXOba+N2VI!$)au-T5&G&ZV+5nRIn%%47{Eq~Un{ z@kF5b2{prMUY?ujhNF8|$*jHw#%i(yiY4xeV@g$EKhG!snQFU@vpm7t`aP>G+=+Ydh9M9@ua9 z*~0OKs>R;>wG(M(9W#H~nwe>GCL7OI-}!0@v?dJL4iJ9+e_ep=Zh*7+3W@z~oFN-q zka@H&Ph+-|m|2+3U(;u1vW+M_GsUjLoh%LbXy)P5Pwi(~5ZRf1hySz{(8k+)! z+$@jyPV(=CGfT}cGAI{j;jPE^Kl1Ef@%c@EGF@)LMdYRrmi#koty#5?0yiuImn26A z9dEAO`?a3J9u>i3pKfIM3(KN!ZD#JRee4$eZ2S46ke2>BybIKfrO6GDt<|_`FEOr-**S0T{Toy=yG{ zwU%95+b%XpK0;Fj`M+$FYhoLU$uv1Ylo%V(`MPg%lL}ZUJfq1tbtGIrm_d78%xDce zCfpbs-&Td_rMj1eylfxpyckoL)^KEa@M(e2z6DPzj#-%NOTa%gFfEkpb+A>$h95y# z@K>|YDq~!EaU_bF$EYNEPkMJ$kBp2sC>9~f4rIr#e$70)`$)TE80(MYX-<6CT~*H8 zv4hqIL-&S$>=51hzB^Y{bjBUCC5u!MUD4|8nbukdvzYLQfl3lwrF0XgW~A?B74c9L zJdz2MlXI?ON42%69UZ^tGKFX5IX!^ZF^N>9QhIPVZ2E{rh@0NQ-JNUj!#%LVg(%yH z!E&y0SGSLU$7)uU_~QADUxi-R7%g~53h}x_eh4ZRj|(6(^KY#yMTSasrIc4D6lrLI zv8nV*ezZd40wGg$vam3d-M}QyQ7@axfZ+MtP zFr|}u`7b&+j)&8=V^XmXd%?!E$w+1^ixBjuQmr0nfX(j;3N2gx>ZWn<)*;Y(XstV1 zsmHNBI%W{}3)#!teWvC`qvRrYwq+$~x&uZg3i{ zEg>-hx^lMhpk%A3+mhDCa#ORlSi2l6;;J`Y1s+~EMsWyxH#p-o-gFdJSh#Z=s<15N zg{(5o65&M#NEPFJmuOt;(0T7)`do|Hz1}h%DK-+k$7I%MqjiYM4FbTSKre|s-5>@NN${G z?e4Y^>s!=g>vR6vXzW;0>B-(I+?u`MdM8j~YmQys{fwAYz1v?J~o zZ5S6fxH@W!UpSzRlvF{!5}s4bAAM^sZuUVt&YW1tN7Z|Gc2u%embj0Bw4GjbCo<(!B+WZZNj zqi&Mr^0ka?>S4TNzE0;sz#jB>dRzQ zT~Kw$wm#+quIAQCnYL`-{AI96H%~5~6i4CZZQdx740nbd?kvH%>~>SjE&F~~cFdfW zM>L}ZT4sHjykB&e7SPB`V^WZv_PU(GjtW7HKk}}J#o_)TQemxByj6_4XMOald^N3l zK*OU{yw>3%3^cB^NWA3Dayx{z(@~-i^c1C3!eUpnRkXJ>kKf&PL-R?!RK!kife}#& z0Ud=pZ(B;EzQ>A=)u-C6xZkl)dbp5A-p{%1JUI~>sO_L>--A;YMlG8NZmUj(r?bQJ z#3EM)HY@5axq*{GCLSs~GygrR;{DKkW_sWD%FY56Kz%feFJj`i#Z>f}l9-4jA0cT8HBQ zmPdO5j9d&)N=u|zJ`7zlfVS5&VMq%@DLWGEqFP`UAy*_YhZI6qNxV}PC;c!tEbr!~ z&^aGqIX`Vp&*gNfTc-pqtEc$d_@h{scHu{3H19$+bepuFUAeB8_Mjxoza+R5h4r$i zyU=?tQkwQK#Um*1g1X+#kd?Ls - - - - - - - - - - - +If this discussion comes up again, we suggest running some more benchmarks and ensuring the performance characteristics do not change dramatically. We do not foresee any architectural problems with that. It mostly comes down to price, performance, and product discussions. Note that you can quickly test this by disallowing certain nodes to have shards on them. Some important considerations is whether reference tables should still be present on query nodes, and whether there are any behavioural differences between query nodes and the coordinator.