It seems like the decision for 2PC is more complicated than
it should be.
With this change, we do one behavioral change. In essense,
before this commit, when a SELECT task with replication factor > 1
is executed, the executor was triggering 2PC. And, in fact,
the transaction manager (`ConnectionModifiedPlacement()`) was
able to understand not to trigger 2PC when no modification happens.
However, for transaction blocks like:
BEGIN;
-- a command that triggers 2PC
-- A SELECT command on replication > 1
..
COMMIT;
The SELECT was used to be qualified as required 2PC. And, as a side-effect
the executor was setting `xactProperties.errorOnAnyFailure = true;`
So, the commands was failing at the time of execution. Now, they fail at
the end of the transaction.
In the past, we allowed users to manually switch to 1PC
(e.g., one phase commit). However, with this commit, we
don't. All multi-shard modifications are done via 2PC.
With Citus 9.0, we introduced `citus.single_shard_commit_protocol` which
defaults to 2PC.
With this commit, we prevent any user to set it to 1PC and drop support
for `citus.single_shard_commit_protocol`.
Although this might add some overhead for users, it is already the default
behaviour (so less likely) and marking placements as INVALID is much
worse.
- citus_get_all_dependencies_for_object: emulate what Citus
would qualify as
dependency when adding
a new node
- citus_get_dependencies_for_object: emulate what Citus would qualify
as dependency when creating an
object
Example use:
```SQL
-- find all the depedencies of table test
SELECT
pg_identify_object(t.classid, t.objid, t.objsubid)
FROM
(SELECT * FROM pg_get_object_address('table', '{test}', '{}')) as addr
JOIN LATERAL
citus_get_all_dependencies_for_object(addr.classid, addr.objid, addr.objsubid) as t(classid oid, objid oid, objsubid int)
ON TRUE
ORDER BY 1;
```
To run tests in parallel use:
```bash
make check-arbitrary-configs parallel=4
```
To run tests sequentially use:
```bash
make check-arbitrary-configs parallel=1
```
To run only some configs:
```bash
make check-arbitrary-base CONFIGS=CitusSingleNodeClusterConfig,CitusSmallSharedPoolSizeConfig
```
To run only some test files with some config:
```bash
make check-arbitrary-base CONFIGS=CitusSingleNodeClusterConfig EXTRA_TESTS=dropped_columns_1
```
To get a deterministic run, you can give the random's seed:
```bash
make check-arbitrary-configs parallel=4 seed=12312
```
The `seed` will be in the output of the run.
In our regular regression tests, we can see all the details about either planning or execution but this means
we need to run the same query under different configs/cluster setups again and again, which is not really maintanable.
When we don't care about the internals of how planning/execution is done but the correctness, especially with different configs
this infrastructure can be used.
With `check-arbitrary-configs` target, the following happens:
- a bunch of configs are loaded, which are defined in `config.py`. These configs have different settings such as different shard count, different citus settings, postgres settings, worker amount, or different metadata.
- For each config, a separate data directory is created for tests in `tmp_citus_test` with the config's name.
- For each config, `create_schedule` is run on the coordinator to setup the necessary tables.
- For each config, `sql_schedule` is run. `sql_schedule` is run on the coordinator if it is a non-mx cluster. And if it is mx, it is either run on the coordinator or a random worker.
- Tests results are checked if they match with the expected.
When tests results don't match, you can see the regression diffs in a config's datadir, such as `tmp_citus_tests/dataCitusSingleNodeClusterConfig`.
We also have a PostgresConfig which runs all the test suite with Postgres.
By default configs use regular user, but we have a config to run as a superuser as well.
So the infrastructure tests:
- Postgres vs Citus
- Mx vs Non-Mx
- Superuser vs regular user
- Arbitrary Citus configs
When you want to add a new test, you can add the create statements to `create_schedule` and add the sql queries to `sql_schedule`.
If you are adding Citus UDFs that should be a NO-OP for Postgres, make sure to override the UDFs in `postgres.sql`.
You can add your new config to `config.py`. Make sure to extend either `CitusDefaultClusterConfig` or `CitusMXBaseClusterConfig`.
On the CI, upon a failure, all logfiles will be uploaded as artifacts, so you can check the artifacts tab.
All the regressions will be shown as part of the job on CI.
In your local, you can check the regression diffs in config's datadirs as in `tmp_citus_tests/dataCitusSingleNodeClusterConfig`.
Add/fix tests
Fix creating partitions
Add test for mx - partition creating case
Enable cascading to partitioned tables
Fix mx partition adding test
Fix cascading through fkeys
Style
Disable converting with non-inherited fkeys
Fix detach bug
Early return in case of cascade & Add tests
Style
Fix undistribute_table bug & Fix test outputs
Remove RemovePartitionRelationIds
Test with undistribute_table
Add test for mx+convert+undistribute
Remove redundant usage of CreatePartitionedCitusLocalTable
Add some comments
Introduce bulk functions for generating attach/detach partition commands
Fix: Convert partitioned tables after adding fkey
Change the error message for partitions
Introduce function ErrorIfPartitionTableAddedToMetadata
Polish attach/detach command generation functions
Use time_partitions for testing
Move mx tests to citus_local_tables_mx
Add new partitioned table to cascade test
Add test with time series management UDFs
Fix test output
Fix: Assertion fail on relation access tracking
Style
Refactor creating partitioned citus local tables
Remove CreatePartitionedCitusLocalTable
Style
Error out if converting multi-level table
Revert some old tests
Error out adding partitioned partition
Polish
Polish/address
Fix create table partition of case
Use CascadeOperationForRelationIdList if no cascade needed
Fix create partition bug
Revert / Add new tests to mx
Style
Fix dropping fkey bug
Add test with IF NOT EXISTS
Convert to CLT when doing ATTACH PARTITION
Add comments
Add more tests with time series management
Edit the error message for converting the child
Use OR instead of AND in ErrorIfUnsupportedAlterTableStmt
Edit/improve tests
Disable ddl prop when dropping default column definitions
Disable/enable ddl prop just before/after the command
Add comment
Add sequence test
Add trigger test
Remove NeedCascadeViaForeignKeys
Add one more insert to sequence test
Add comment
Style
Fix test output shard ids
Update comments
Disable creating fkey on partitions
Move partition check to CreateCitusLocalTable
Add comment
Add check for attachingmulti-level partition
Add test for pg_constraint
Check pg_dist_partition in tests
Add test inserting on the worker
Nils Dijk
Jelte Fennema
Philip Dubé
Onder Kalaci
Önder Kalacı
Marco Slot
Sait Talha Nisanci
Halil Ozan Akgul
Ahmet Gedemenli
Hanefi Onaldi
Teja Mupparti
Onur Tirtir